
Tiffany takes on the world!
Tiffany Anderson likes climbing mountains.
Literally.
The founding fifth-grade ELA teacher at Achievement First Legacy has trekked through Patagonia, India, Japan and the Alps. In Peru, she has hiked at elevations approaching 15,000 feet.
![]()
What Tiffany loves is the challenge: putting herself in a situation that initially feels difficult or uncomfortable, working through it and eventually discovering that she is capable of more than she thought.
It turns out that’s also a pretty good description of Tiffany’s career at Achievement First.
After more than a decade at AF Bushwick, Tiffany chose to transfer to Legacy. She had worked with Principal D’Asia Adger at Bushwick and knew how difficult launching a new school could be. She also knew what she could bring to it: years of experience, high expectations for herself and her students, and a deep belief that great schools are built by teachers who take their craft seriously.
A few months into the school year, Tiffany says Legacy is off to a strong start. She describes her new fifth graders as bright, curious students whose families are deeply invested in their success. And because this is a founding year, Tiffany and her colleagues aren’t just thinking about what students need today. They are establishing habits and traditions they hope will define Legacy for years to come.
It would have been much easier for Tiffany to stay where she was.

The road to achievement
She joined AF Bushwick Elementary in 2012 and spent more than a decade in the Bushwick community, teaching across multiple grade levels before eventually moving to Bushwick Middle. She taught siblings from the same families and watched former students progress through middle and high school. Parents continued texting her years after their children left her classroom. She even lives in Bushwick and still runs into former students walking through the neighborhood.
But Tiffany has never been particularly interested in getting comfortable. She has spent her career looking for the next challenge, and figuring out how to become a better teacher in order to meet it.
One of her proudest moments came in 2019, when 99 percent of her third-grade students scored proficient on the New York State ELA assessment. Tiffany doesn’t describe those results as magic. She remembers a year of studying data, constantly adjusting instruction and running intervention groups to make sure nearly every student received exactly what they needed.
When students returned from the pandemic with significant unfinished learning, Tiffany found a new challenge. She remembers one third grader who introduced herself by telling Tiffany that she couldn’t read. The student had moved from Honduras during the pandemic, learned to speak English largely through Zoom, but hadn’t learned to read. With intensive support, she finished third grade reading on grade level. Today, Tiffany says, that student is an eighth grader performing well above grade level and preparing to apply to specialized high schools.
Tiffany saw the opportunity to join Legacy both as a new challenge for herself and a chance to share what she had learned over more than a decade at AF with a new generation of teachers.
The move has required some sacrifices. After years of walking 10 or 15 minutes to work, Tiffany now commutes from Bushwick to Queens, a trip that can take more than an hour each way.
But Tiffany has found a use for that time.
Despite teaching for more than a decade, she still practices her lessons. On the train, she rehearses her questions and thinks through how students might respond. She grades. She listens to podcasts and books about teaching and learning; recently, she was listening to Powerful Teaching and thinking about how to incorporate strategies for helping students retain what they learn.
Now she has set another ambitious target: after reaching 75 percent proficiency with her students last year, Tiffany wants to see whether her new fifth graders at Legacy can reach 90 percent proficiency this year.
She doesn’t know yet whether they’ll get there.
But uncertainty has never been much of a deterrent for Tiffany. From moving from Florida to Hawaii for college, to serving three years in the Peace Corps in West Africa, to hiking across mountains on the other side of the world, some of the most meaningful experiences of her life have begun with the decision to leave someplace comfortable.
Now, after more than a decade at Achievement First, she is doing it again.
New school. New students. New commute. New goal.
Another mountain to climb.


